7 Secrets To Scoring The Best Finds At One More Time Store: An Insider’s Guide To Columbus’s Resale Gem
As of December 26, 2025, the name "One More Time Store" represents a rich tapestry of resale experiences across the United States, but the true cornerstone of this brand legacy resides in Columbus, Ohio. This "One More Time Family" of stores has solidified its reputation as Central Ohio’s premier consignment destination, boasting an impressive history of over 45 years in the resale industry. Far from being a typical thrift shop, this establishment offers a curated, high-quality selection of pre-loved items, making it a must-visit for both seasoned thrifters and discerning shoppers looking for sustainable, unique finds.
The success of the brand is largely due to its dual focus: one location dedicated to fashion and accessories, and another, "One More Time Etc," specializing in furniture and home decor. This separation allows each store to offer an in-depth and focused inventory, ensuring a superior shopping experience that has kept customers returning for decades. Whether you are hunting for vintage apparel or a unique piece of pre-owned furniture, understanding the store's operations and consignment model is key to maximizing your haul.
The One More Time Family: A Dual-Location Resale Empire
The "One More Time" concept in Columbus, Ohio, is not a single entity but a coordinated family of stores, each dedicated to a specific category of resale. This model has allowed them to become specialists in their respective domains, providing a quality of inventory that often surpasses standard thrift or second-hand shops. Their commitment to quality and longevity—over four decades of service—makes them a trusted name in the local resale market.
One More Time Consignment (Clothing & Accessories)
- Focus: Men's and Women's Clothing, Shoes, and Fashion Accessories.
- Experience: Over 45 years in the resale clothing market.
- Vibe: Often described as a hidden gem for high-quality, second-hand fashion in a welcoming environment.
- Location: Located in the Grandview area of Columbus, OH.
One More Time Etc (Furniture & Home Decor)
- Focus: Indoor Furniture, Patio Furniture, Home Decor, and Unique Household Items.
- Experience: Also boasts over 45 years of experience in furniture consignment.
- Vibe: Captivates shoppers with an eclectic selection of gently used furniture and decorative pieces.
- Inventory USP: Known for a constantly moving, unique inventory that changes often, unlike big-box stores.
7 Insider Secrets to Mastering the One More Time Shopping Experience
To truly unlock the value and unique finds at the One More Time stores, you need to shop with intention. Their high-quality consignment model means the inventory is better curated but also moves faster. Here are seven secrets to help you score the best pre-loved items.
1. Master the "Consignment Cycle" for New Arrivals
The inventory at both the clothing and furniture stores is constantly refreshed by consignors bringing in items daily. The secret is to understand their consignment process. While they accept items every day, the actual process of sorting, pricing, and placing items on the floor takes time. Visit the stores mid-week, particularly Tuesday through Thursday, to catch items that have been processed since the weekend rush. This timing often allows you to browse fresh stock before the larger crowds arrive on Friday and Saturday.
2. Prioritize "One More Time Etc" for Eclectic Home Decor
If your goal is unique home furnishings, focus on the "Etc" location. Reviewers consistently note that the selection of indoor furniture, patio furniture, and home accessories is vibrant and eclectic. Unlike traditional furniture stores, this consignment model guarantees that the inventory is constantly changing, offering truly unique pieces—from vintage side tables to high-quality patio sets—that you won't find anywhere else.
3. Leverage the "Cash vs. Credit" Consignor Model
One More Time offers consignors the option of cash for their items or in-store credit. This is a crucial piece of information for the savvy shopper. Consignors who opt for in-store credit are often looking to quickly spend that credit on new finds within the store. This creates a natural, internal cycle of high-quality items rotating back onto the floor, often leading to a better overall selection of quality used clothing and accessories.
4. Hunt for High-End and Designer Labels
Because the store has a reputation for accepting only "quality new and used items," it attracts consignors with higher-end brands. Unlike a traditional thrift store where you might have to dig through hundreds of low-quality items, One More Time is a premier destination for second-hand fashion, meaning the likelihood of finding designer labels or boutique-quality apparel is significantly higher. Take the time to meticulously check the racks and the accessories section for these valuable scores.
5. Know the Difference: Consignment vs. Thrift
It is essential to manage your price expectations. One More Time is a consignment and resale shop, not a donation-based thrift store. This means the prices, while still offering significant savings over retail, reflect the higher quality, better condition, and curation of the items. Embrace this distinction; you are paying a fair price for a more reliable, quality-checked item, saving you time and effort compared to sifting through less curated stock.
6. Utilize the Two Locations for a Complete Resale Experience
The two Columbus locations are situated close enough to each other that they can be visited in a single trip, offering the "ultimate resale experience." Plan your day to hit both the clothing store and the furniture store. By combining the hunt for fashion accessories, men's and women's clothing, and home decor, you maximize your chances of finding all your needs met in one convenient resale hub in Central Ohio.
7. Check the Accessories and Small Decor First
Often, the best deals and most unique finds are in the smaller categories. For clothing, the accessories (jewelry, bags, scarves) are often overlooked by shoppers but can contain vintage treasures. For home decor, the small items like lamps, wall art, and decorative pieces at One More Time Etc are what give the store its "eclectic selection" reputation and are frequently refreshed. Start your browsing here to warm up your thrifting eye before tackling the larger clothing racks and furniture displays.
The Impact of the Resale Model on Sustainability and Community
The enduring success of the One More Time stores, with their decades of resale experience, highlights a powerful trend toward sustainable shopping. By prioritizing the sale of pre-owned, gently used furniture and clothing, the store actively participates in the circular economy. This business model significantly reduces textile waste and the demand for new furniture production, offering an environmentally conscious alternative to fast fashion and disposable home goods.
Furthermore, the consignment process benefits the local community directly. Consignors receive cash or credit for their quality used items, providing a financial incentive for sustainable practices. The store acts as a vital middle ground, connecting sellers who want to declutter with buyers who desire unique, affordable, and high-quality items, thereby strengthening the local economy in the Grandview and Central Ohio areas. The "One More Time Family" is a testament to how a well-managed, quality-focused consignment shop can thrive for over 45 years, becoming a cornerstone for vintage enthusiasts and budget-conscious consumers alike.
Detail Author:
- Name : Miguel Konopelski
- Username : orion.bartell
- Email : hulda.white@jacobson.biz
- Birthdate : 1978-07-24
- Address : 6340 Roscoe Isle East Jerrold, AR 14282
- Phone : 1-810-899-4170
- Company : Lesch LLC
- Job : Sociology Teacher
- Bio : Delectus nisi veniam odio nihil enim illo unde. Amet quam quaerat ut qui velit. Ut tenetur quia autem at sit.
Socials
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/sincere_official
- username : sincere_official
- bio : Et suscipit ab fugiat.
- followers : 3372
- following : 159
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/sincere.dibbert
- username : sincere.dibbert
- bio : Quos praesentium nihil in corporis. Laudantium consequatur eaque at maxime iure est.
- followers : 5784
- following : 1966
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/sincere1130
- username : sincere1130
- bio : Eum eos aut vel unde est ut aut.
- followers : 1005
- following : 1662
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/sinceredibbert
- username : sinceredibbert
- bio : Ut reprehenderit voluptatibus consequatur vero doloremque at molestiae. Nihil qui ut vel.
- followers : 6061
- following : 1392
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@dibbert1978
- username : dibbert1978
- bio : Illo perspiciatis ex laborum distinctio qui. Ex praesentium dicta sit incidunt.
- followers : 2441
- following : 1948
