Home Global Impact

10 Secret Menu Hacks At Long John Silver's You Must Try Today (Updated For 2025)

• minute read
Contents

Are you tired of the same old Fish and Chips order at Long John Silver's? As of December 25, 2025, the fast-food seafood chain may not have an "official" secret menu like some competitors, but a vibrant community of fans and knowledgeable staff have created an incredible list of off-menu customizations and "hacks" that can transform your next meal into a truly unique, deep-sea adventure. These insider items leverage existing ingredients to create legendary, unlisted favorites, from spicy sandwiches to healthier grilled options and even a nostalgic blast from the past.

The key to mastering the Long John Silver's secret menu is simple: know the ingredients and be polite. Since these items require minor assembly or specific requests, a little friendliness goes a long way with the crew. Get ready to sail past the standard menu and discover the culinary treasures that only true "Seacret Society" members know about.

The Top 10 Must-Try Long John Silver's Off-Menu Hacks

The best Long John Silver's secret menu items are not entirely new recipes, but rather clever combinations, customizations, or special requests that elevate the existing menu. Here are the most popular and widely available hacks you should order on your next visit. Each hack is a testament to the versatility of their core offerings, like the Wild Alaska Pollock and famous batter.

1. The Extra Crumblies (The Gold Standard Hack)

This is arguably the most famous "secret" item and a non-negotiable hack for any true LJS fan. The "Crumblies" are the delicious, crispy bits of fried batter that fall off the fish and shrimp during the frying process. They are the essence of the Long John Silver's flavor.

  • How to Order: Simply ask the cashier for a side of "Extra Crumblies." In many locations, they are free or available for a very small, nominal charge.
  • Why It's Great: They add a salty, crunchy texture to any meal. Use them as a topping for your fries, a garnish for your coleslaw, or just eat them by the handful.

2. Surf and Turf Sliders

This savory hack is for customers who can't decide between land and sea. It’s a simple combination of their battered fish and their all-white meat chicken.

  • How to Order: Order a piece of battered fish and a piece of battered chicken (or a chicken tender). Then, order a side of rolls (if available) or use the buns from a sandwich order. Assemble your own slider by placing a piece of fish on one bun and a piece of chicken on the other, adding tartar sauce or a dash of malt vinegar.
  • Why It's Great: It offers the best of both worlds in a single, satisfying bite. This is a great way to sample the quality of both the seafood and the poultry offerings.

3. Double-Battered Fish

For those who believe the signature batter is the best part of the fish, this hack is a game-changer. It delivers an extra-thick, extra-crunchy coating.

  • How to Order: Politely ask if they can "Double-Batter" your fish or shrimp. This request may depend on how busy the kitchen is and the willingness of the staff, but it's a known customization.
  • Why It's Great: It maximizes the crispy texture and savory flavor of the batter, creating a truly indulgent piece of fried fish.

4. The Spicy Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich

The standard Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich is a classic, but this secret variation adds a much-needed kick of heat. It's a simple customization using readily available condiments.

  • How to Order: Order the regular Wild Alaska Pollock Sandwich and ask for a side of the restaurant's hot sauce or add a packet of Texas Pete or another hot sauce they have on hand.
  • Why It's Great: The spice cuts through the richness of the fried fish and tartar sauce, creating a balanced and flavorful sandwich that's not on the main menu.

Healthier & Flavorful Customizations (The Grilled & Fresh Options)

Long John Silver's isn't just about fried food. They offer a variety of grilled and baked options that can be customized to create fresh, off-menu dishes that cater to a lighter diet. These items leverage the quality of their seafood without the signature batter.

5. Grilled Salmon Meal Customization

While a Grilled Salmon Meal may appear on the menu in some locations, it's often overlooked. The secret is in the customization of the sides and seasoning.

  • How to Order: Order the Grilled Salmon Meal (if available) and ask for it to be served with extra lemon wedges and a side of steamed rice (if available) instead of fries. You can also ask for a dash of their seasoning blend to be added before grilling.
  • Why It's Great: It’s a high-protein, omega-3-rich meal that feels more like a fast-casual offering than typical fast food.

6. Healthier Shrimp and Fish Tacos

This is a great, lighter alternative to the fried planks and baskets. It's a simple assembly hack that creates a fresh, vibrant meal.

  • How to Order: Order a side of grilled shrimp or a piece of grilled fish (Wild Alaska Pollock is a great choice) and a side of tortillas (if available). Use the lettuce, tomatoes, and other available toppings (like salsa or sour cream, if stocked) to build your own fresh tacos.
  • Why It's Great: It’s a quick, fresh, and customizable meal that focuses on the quality of the seafood.

7. Fried Clams (The Regional Rarity)

Fried Clams are a staple in some coastal LJS locations but are often absent from the menus in landlocked states. This item is a check on regional availability.

  • How to Order: Simply ask if they have "Fried Clams." If they do, you've unlocked a delicious, often-discontinued item that tastes incredible with their cocktail sauce.
  • Why It's Great: When available, they offer a unique texture and flavor profile that breaks up the routine of fish and shrimp.

Nostalgic Favorites and Cross-Chain Combos

The secret menu also includes a few nostalgic shout-outs to discontinued items and a clever hack that utilizes LJS's unique co-branded locations.

8. The Shrimp Cheesy Gordita Crunch (Co-Branded Locations)

This legendary hack is only possible at combined Long John Silver's and Taco Bell locations, which are common across the country. It combines the best of both worlds.

  • How to Order: Order a Cheesy Gordita Crunch from the Taco Bell menu, but ask for it *without* the seasoned beef. Then, order a side of fried shrimp from the Long John Silver's menu. Carefully insert the fried shrimp into the Cheesy Gordita Crunch shell and add a squeeze of Baja Sauce.
  • Why It's Great: It’s a decadent, salty, crunchy, and savory mashup that has achieved legendary status in the fast-food hack community.

9. The Mythical Peg Legs (The Discontinued Dream)

While not a hack you can order today, the "Peg Legs" were a discontinued favorite that speaks to the chain's history. They were essentially deep-fried chicken drumsticks, often served alongside the seafood platters in the 1970s and 80s.

  • How to Order: You can't. However, you can ask for a side of battered chicken tenders and pretend! The fact that LJS once served a perfectly battered chicken drumstick is a fun piece of trivia to share with the staff.
  • Why It's Great: It’s a piece of LJS lore that demonstrates the chain’s ability to perfectly fry anything, even non-seafood items.

10. The Ultimate Fish Sandwich Upgrade

Take the standard Fish Sandwich and maximize its flavor and texture with a simple ingredient swap.

  • How to Order: Order the standard Fish Sandwich. Ask to substitute the tartar sauce with their creamy Ranch dressing or a side of malt vinegar for a tangier profile. Additionally, ask for a small handful of "Extra Crumblies" to be sprinkled inside the sandwich for an added layer of crunch.
  • Why It's Great: It allows you to tailor the classic sandwich to your exact taste preference, moving beyond the standard condiments to a richer, more complex flavor.

Mastering the Art of Ordering Off-Menu

When approaching the counter to order your secret menu items, remember that these are not official menu offerings, and the staff may not recognize the exact names like "Surf and Turf Sliders." Your success depends on clear, polite communication and understanding the ingredients.

Use the "Ingredient-Based" Approach: Instead of asking for the "Double-Battered Fish," ask: "Could I please get a piece of fish, and is it possible to have it double-battered?" This language is more direct and less likely to confuse a new crew member. Always be prepared to pay a small upcharge for extra ingredients or special preparation, although many of these hacks are simple customizations.

Check for Discontinued Items: Items like the Corn on the Cob or Fried Clams are often regional or seasonal. A simple, polite inquiry like "Do you happen to still carry the Corn on the Cob?" can sometimes unlock a forgotten favorite that hasn't been officially removed from all locations.

By using these menu hacks and customizations, you can unlock a whole new world of flavor at Long John Silver's. The true secret menu is not a printed list, but the creative potential of their delicious, battered ingredients combined with the imagination of their dedicated fans.

10 Secret Menu Hacks at Long John Silver's You Must Try Today (Updated for 2025)
long john silvers secret menu
long john silvers secret menu

Detail Author:

  • Name : Lilian Stoltenberg
  • Username : bosco.luisa
  • Email : turcotte.myrtis@yahoo.com
  • Birthdate : 1985-10-11
  • Address : 1102 Maurine Camp Apt. 832 East Lillyport, GA 01447-3923
  • Phone : 952.433.2788
  • Company : Medhurst PLC
  • Job : Separating Machine Operators
  • Bio : Eos quia velit animi veritatis enim blanditiis quis. Aliquid rerum corrupti inventore quaerat voluptates explicabo. Qui est aut reiciendis.

Socials

linkedin:

facebook:

instagram:

  • url : https://instagram.com/gertrude8670
  • username : gertrude8670
  • bio : Itaque sit autem eligendi ea sit natus repudiandae. Quae dolorem impedit voluptatum.
  • followers : 3373
  • following : 2831

twitter:

  • url : https://twitter.com/gertrude_real
  • username : gertrude_real
  • bio : Molestias ut fuga laudantium eum reiciendis assumenda. Aperiam ea hic nihil laborum qui vero. Est sapiente qui quaerat non.
  • followers : 1992
  • following : 521

tiktok:

  • url : https://tiktok.com/@gertrude_xx
  • username : gertrude_xx
  • bio : Corporis qui sunt autem facere aut nobis voluptate. Atque ad enim quia omnis.
  • followers : 6470
  • following : 1160

Random Posts