The End Of An Era? 7 Shocking Facts About Catalina Beach Club Atlantic Beach NY After Its Historic 2025 Sale Listing
The Catalina Beach Club in Atlantic Beach, New York, is currently at the center of a major real estate buzz, marking a potentially dramatic shift for Long Island's exclusive South Shore. This iconic private club, a historic summer retreat that has maintained its classic Art Deco charm for over 80 years, was officially listed for sale in mid-2025, creating unprecedented speculation among long-time members and real estate investors alike.
Operating continuously since 1944 under the same family ownership, the Catalina Beach Club is more than just a seasonal destination; it is a cultural landmark. As of today, December 23, 2025, the club remains a hot topic, not just for its stunning oceanfront location but for the monumental decision by the founding family to finally sell the property, a move that will redefine the future of beach club culture in Nassau County.
The Historic Sale and Ownership Profile
The decision to list the Catalina Beach Club for sale in 2025 is the single most significant piece of news surrounding the property in its entire history. For eight decades, the club has been a private, family-run institution, making this sale a truly once-in-a-lifetime commercial real estate opportunity.
- Property Name: Catalina Beach Club
- Location: 2045 Ocean Blvd, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509
- Founding Year: 1944
- Original Owners: The Carasso Family (Purchased in 1944)
- Current Status: Listed for sale (Date on Market: July 15, 2025)
- Distance from NYC: Approximately 21 miles
- Architectural Style: Classic Art Deco, maintained since its establishment
- Operational Season: Memorial Day Weekend through Labor Day Weekend
The club was put on the market by its founders and their descendants for the very first time, a fact that highlights the rarity and value of the property. This massive listing has attracted national attention, with the price being an open bid, signaling a high-stakes transaction for one of the last privately-owned, historic beach clubs on the South Shore of Long Island.
What Makes Catalina Beach Club a Long Island Institution?
The Catalina Beach Club’s enduring appeal lies in its ability to transport members back to a golden age of summer leisure. It has successfully resisted the urge to fully modernize, preserving the nostalgic Art Deco architecture that defines its character.
The Enduring Art Deco Charm
The club’s main structure and facilities boast a distinctive Art Deco style, a nod to the era when many of Long Island’s premier beach clubs were first constructed in the late 1920s and 1930s. This architectural preservation provides a unique, vintage atmosphere that is a stark contrast to many contemporary resorts. Members often speak of the club feeling like a genuine escape, a place where tradition holds sway over fleeting trends.
The entire property is situated in the small, exclusive village of Atlantic Beach, a prime oceanfront location that offers stunning views and easy access to the pristine beach. The club serves as a summer retreat for families from Long Island and New York City, looking for a convenient, high-end seasonal getaway.
Premier Amenities for the 2025 Season
Despite the sale listing, the Catalina Beach Club operated as planned for the 2025 summer season, offering its full suite of amenities to members. The club is designed to cater to all aspects of a luxury summer experience, from active recreation to pure relaxation.
- Cabanas and Lockers: Members have the option to rent private cabanas or beach lockers, which are essential for a full season of beach-going.
- Pool Area: A spacious, well-maintained swimming pool is available for both leisure and exercise, complementing the ocean swimming experience.
- Rooftop Deck: A popular feature is the rooftop deck, which is perfect for sunbathing and offers panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean.
- Dining: The on-site cafe provides convenient dining options throughout the day.
- Beach Access: Direct and easy access to the private Atlantic Beach shoreline is the club’s core offering.
The club also hosts special events, including vendor days, with applications for the 2025 season being available to both members and non-members.
Navigating the Current Controversies and Future Outlook
The club’s historic sale is not the only recent development to make headlines. Like many legacy institutions, the Catalina Beach Club has faced challenges that add layers of complexity to its current valuation and public profile.
The 2025 Labor Lawsuit
In a significant legal development in 2025, a lawsuit was filed against the Catalina Beach Club by a group of employees, including residents from nearby Lynbrook. The suit alleged that approximately 75 employees were underpaid based on current labor standards. This type of legal challenge is a crucial factor for potential new ownership to consider, as it highlights the operational and labor management issues that come with acquiring a long-standing, seasonal business.
The Uncertainty of New Ownership
The biggest question for current members and the Atlantic Beach community is what the future holds under new ownership. The club's identity is deeply tied to the Carasso family's stewardship, which has prioritized the preservation of its mid-century charm. A new owner could potentially:
- Maintain Tradition: Continue the current business model, focusing on the exclusive, nostalgic experience.
- Modernize: Invest heavily in renovations, potentially expanding the facilities or updating the Art Deco aesthetic.
- Redevelop: The most drastic scenario, where the prime oceanfront real estate is redeveloped into luxury condominiums or a different type of resort, though this would face significant local opposition.
The sale process is a pivotal moment that will determine whether the Catalina Beach Club remains a private, seasonal Art Deco retreat or transforms into a new entity entirely. The club's legacy, spanning over 80 years, ensures that its future will be closely watched by those who cherish this unique piece of Long Island history.
Detail Author:
- Name : Hillard Medhurst
- Username : scot.hand
- Email : ernestine.cummings@hotmail.com
- Birthdate : 2000-04-26
- Address : 126 Emard Fork Larsonton, WA 04632
- Phone : 754-554-9080
- Company : Padberg-Weber
- Job : Camera Repairer
- Bio : Libero autem architecto dolorem dolorum consectetur. Porro odio cupiditate iste.
Socials
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@ilalindgren
- username : ilalindgren
- bio : Ut voluptatibus eius sit ad unde neque.
- followers : 1299
- following : 2853
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/ila_xx
- username : ila_xx
- bio : Architecto voluptates rem quo rem doloribus sed ut. Nobis consectetur et nemo itaque blanditiis et. Enim cupiditate magnam porro nesciunt corporis.
- followers : 3591
- following : 80
